Additional settings for Safari Browser.
Honors
Carroll Chargers All-Conference Players
Allen County Athletic Conference (1969 - 1989)
Northeast Hoosier Conference(1990 - 2015)
Summit Athletic Conference (2016 - Present)
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 1969 | Dave McComb, Mike Mills | |
| 1970 | Jim Kruse | |
| 1971 | Jim Kruse | |
| 1972 | Larry Fitch | |
| 1973 | Dennis McComb | |
| 1974 | Rick Faylor, Rick Warner | |
| 1975 | Rick Faylor | |
| 1976 | Lennie Shank | |
| 1977 | Rick Myers, Lennie Shank, Jeff Warner | |
| 1978 | Rick Myers, Lennie Shank, Jeff Warner | |
| 1979 | None | |
| 1980 | None | |
| 1981 | None | |
| 1982 | Brad Gumbert | |
| 1983 | Mike Clark, Mark Merryman | |
| 1984 | Brian Lonergan, Mark Merryman | |
| 1985 | Curtis Camp, Brian Lonergan, Mark Sordelet | |
| 1986 | Kevin Shank | |
| 1987 | Steve Coblentz, Kevin Shank | |
| 1988 | Paul Johnson, Scott Pfafman | |
| 1989 | Paul Johnson, Scott Lahrman | |
| 1990 | Paul Johnson | T.D. Rolf |
| 1991 | Karsten Lochmueller | Jason Sheets |
| 1992 | Karsten Lochmueller | Joe Pliett, Ryan Rolf, Jason Sheets |
| 1993 | Noel Nitecki | Kurt Grau, Joe Pliett |
| 1994 | Noel Nitecki | Greg Gump |
| 1995 | Dan Gilbert | Troy Lefevra |
| 1996 | None | Chad Wells |
| 1997 | Brett Macy, Dan Scharlach | Erik Hilger |
| 1998 | Sam Gensic | Ryan Delagrange, Kevin Clopton |
| 1999 | Sam Gensic, Gabe Miller | Luke Amstutz |
| 2000 | Dave Mahlan, Gabe Miller | Luke Amstutz, Scott Bushong |
| 2001 | Scott Bushong, Gabe Miller | Matt Ogle |
| 2002 | Seth Lochmueller | Drew Poston |
| 2003 | Seth Lochmueller | None |
| 2004 | Deric Faylor | John Bates, Andrew Bourne, Blake Pond |
| 2005 | Deric Faylor | Zach Taylor |
| 2006 | None | Jarad Miller, Zach Taylor |
| 2007 | Jarad Miller, Zach Taylor | Mitch Schaefer |
| 2008 | Max Killion, Dominic Spadafora | Durane Harris |
| 2009 | Conner Blasi, Tyler Ault | Brandon Kinsey, Cam Ginder, Stephen Jones |
| 2010 | Shane Merryman, Stephen Jones, Tyler Ault | Alex Hipskind |
| 2011 | Tyler Ault | Erik Ward |
| 2012 | Chandler White | Jonathan McKeeman |
| 2013 | Chandler White | Mason Miller |
| 2014 | Chandler White, Kyle Mallers | Jeremy Kalonji |
| 2015 | Chandler White, Kyle Mallers, Jeremy Kalonji | Jacob Redding |
| 2016 | Kyle Mallers, Jacob Redding | Kelham Brown |
| 2017 | Jacob Redding | Anthony Martin |
| 2018 | Arius Jones, David Ejah | Dan McKeeman, Riley Perlich |
| 2019 | David Ejah, Dan McKeeman | Preston Shearer |
| 2020 | Richie Gross, Jalen Jackson | Ryan Preston, Sam Strycker, Ray Vollmer |
| 2021 | Jalen Jackson, Ryan Preston, Sam Strycker | Cody Burkey |