Carroll players awards include:
*Michael Knitter ('04) as a High School All-American by the National Soccer Coaches Association.
*Dan Fox ('04) - I.H.S.A.A.'s winner of the 2003-04 C. Eugene Cato Mental Attitude Award.
*Tim Wylie ('08) finished his career with Coach Mike Freitag's 2012 National Champion Indiana Hoosiers.